raft2

Combating subconscious greenwashing in digital sustainability: Part 3

Mon, 30 Mar 2026 18:20:14 GMT

The human side of digital accessibility

In the final part of our conversation, Ashley John moves beyond the "carbon tunnel vision" that traps many sustainability professionals. While measuring emissions is vital, Ashley argues that true digital sustainability must account for the social impact: the people behind the screens, the accessibility of information, and the ethics of the tools we use.

Beyond "carbon myopia"

For many, "sustainability" is synonymous with "carbon footprint." But as Ashley points out, focusing solely on emissions is a form of tunnel vision.

"We’re dealing with people," Ashley says. "It’s about the social aspects of sustainability; engaging with communities in a way where they can actually read and understand what’s on your website."

To make this "doing the right thing" accessible to everyone, Ashley has committed to a "freemium" model for his suite of tools. "A lot of companies are priced out of doing the right thing. With EcoPigs , you can monitor one website for free, forever."

A toolkit for radical transparency

Ashley hasn't just stopped at website emissions. He has developed an entire ecosystem of tools designed to strip away the "fluff" and get to the truth:

Noissme.com: A carbon accounting tool (emission spelt backwards) that simplifies Scope 1, 2, and 3 reporting. "I found other tools inundated users with irrelevant questions about refrigerant gases or bioenergy. If you're a creative agency in a shared office, you don't need that. Noisssme strips away the noise."
Swynx: A tool for developers that looks at "code health." It identifies "dead code" and "bloat" that waste energy, while remaining completely air-gapped for security.
Scope 3 Clarity: Ashley is pushing for a focus on Scope 3, the indirect emissions that make up 90% of a company’s impact, rather than just the "tip of the iceberg" Scope 1 and 2 metrics that companies use to look green.

Oynk SE: the social enterprise

Perhaps the most exciting development is the launch of Oynk SE (Social Enterprise) . In Part 2, we discussed the JEDI (Justice, Equality, Diversity, and Inclusion) requirements for B Corp. One of those requirements is that websites must be tested by people with real living disabilities.

In partnership with Tom Cliff of Cafe Track, Ashley is creating a network of neurodivergent and disabled testers to provide manual audits of websites.

"We’re going to give these people real money. It’s life-changing for people who have been ignored or sidelined. They get to provide qualified feedback: 'I struggled to press tab here' or 'it took too long to contact you.' It creates a circular economy of meaningful work and accessible design."

Dirty by design: challenging the status quo

Ashley is now taking his findings to the page in his upcoming book, Dirty by Design , currently being released chapter-by-chapter on Substack.

The book is an antagonist's look at the "assumptions" that have governed digital sustainability for the last decade. Ashley is openly challenging the established giants like the Green Web Foundation, arguing that their methods are based on outdated data and "best guesses."

"I’m not being malicious," Ashley clarifies. "I’m saying: let’s raise the bar. If you’ve had ten years to fix your model and I’ve hammered what you’ve done in 18 months, did you really care? Or was it just more subconscious greenwashing?"

The bottom line

Ashley’s mission is clear: move away from "tick-box" sustainability and toward a defensible, science-based, and human-centric framework. By making tools free, empowering the disabled community, and demanding accuracy over assumptions, he is rewriting the rules of the digital road.

As Ashley puts it: "Everything is there. It’s transparent. If you want to argue with me about the metrics, come to the website and let’s talk. My method is correct because it’s based on fact, not fiction."

This concludes our three-part series on digital sustainability. For more insights into marketing with integrity, subscribe to Sustainability Marketing Survival Conversations.

Combating subconscious greenwashing in digital sustainability: Part 2

Mon, 30 Mar 2026 18:20:12 GMT

The integrity proxy

In Part 1 , Ashley John , founder of Oynk and EcoPigs , pulled back the curtain on the flaws of standard digital carbon calculators. But as our conversation continued, it became clear that digital sustainability isn't just about carbon, it’s about a broader sense of corporate honesty.

If your website is the "front door" to your business, what happens when the welcome mat is a lie?

Can we trust you?

Ashley has coined a powerful term for the modern marketer: the Integrity Proxy . It’s a simple litmus test for brand authenticity.

"If someone wants to know about you, they go to your website first because it’s non-committal," Ashley explains. "If you claim to care about the planet and people, but your website has terrible emissions and fails basic accessibility standards, how can you be trusted?"

For Ashley, a website that ignores these factors isn't just a technical failure; it’s a breach of brand promise. To combat this, Oynk builds with "100% clarity." Every site includes a transparent report and a live "pig badge" that users can click to see the actual methodology and real-time data.

"How can we trust anything else you tell us if your own website isn't even accurate?"

Beyond carbon: the rise of JEDI

The conversation in sustainability is rapidly shifting toward Scope 3 reporting and social impact. Ashley notes that B Corp’s V2 model now includes a critical section called JEDI (Justice, Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion).

This isn't just a "nice to have" anymore; it’s a requirement. For new B Corps, accessibility is now baked into the certification process. This shift aligns perfectly with Ashley’s new framework for digital excellence: PEER.

The Four Pillars of PEER:

Performance: Speed isn't just for UX; every second of load time can cost you 7% of your traffic.

Emissions: Real-time tracking of the digital footprint.

Experience: Ensuring the site works for everyone, regardless of ability.

Ranking: High-performing, low-emission sites naturally rank better on Google.

"When I talked to people about 'sustainability,' they didn't always care," Ashley admits. "But when I talk about a website that ranks higher, loads in under a second, and eliminates bounce rates? Now they're listening."

The high bar of accessibility

One of the most challenging aspects of the JEDI metrics is the Flesch-Kincaid reading level . To reach the gold standard (AAA), website content should be readable by someone at grade 10 or under.

This requires a radical simplification of language that many brands find painful. Ashley shares a recent example: "We had to change 'make a positive change' to 'make a real change.' Why? Because 'positive' has too many syllables. We even struggled with the word 'business' vs 'firm.' It’s a constant back-and-forth to ensure no one is excluded."

This level of detail extends to colour ratios. To meet AAA standards, you need a 7:1 contrast ratio . "I'm eating my own dog food here," Ashley laughs. "I had to rework my own Oynk branding because my yellow and white combo didn't meet the ratio. I can't tell clients to do it if I won't do it myself."

A meaningful digital future

For Ashley, this mission is personal. As someone with autism and ADHD, he understands how exclusionary a poorly designed digital space can be.

"There are people who don't have the capacity to navigate a 'boring' or overly complex site. Are we excluding them from the workplace? From reading the company intranet? From understanding an email?"

By combining EcoPigs' live emissions tracking with the JEDI accessibility framework, Ashley is building more than just websites; he's building a structure for digital integrity. In an era of "subconscious greenwashing," the only way forward is through radical, data-backed transparency.

Digital sustainability is no longer just about the environment; it’s about ensuring the digital world is open, honest, and accessible to everyone.

Combating subconscious greenwashing in digital sustainability: Part 1

Mon, 30 Mar 2026 17:49:37 GMT

A Deep Dive with Ashley John, Founder, Oynk

In the world of sustainable marketing, we often focus on physical supply chains, plastic-free packaging, and carbon-neutral shipping. But an invisible culprit is lurking in our browsers: the digital carbon footprint.

I recently sat down with Ashley John , founder of the digital sustainability and accessibility consultancy Oynk, and the mastermind behind EcoPigs , to discuss why current digital sustainability metrics are failing us and how "subconscious greenwashing" is skewing our understanding of a "green" website.

From Creative Agency to Carbon Calculators

Ashley’s journey didn’t start with a mission to save the planet; it started with a mission to build better websites. In August 2024, Oynk launched as an agency focused on optimised design.

"Low carbon was actually a byproduct of optimisation," Ashley explains. "No one wants a clunky website. Naturally, everything we built was optimised for performance, speed, and emissions."

As he delved deeper into the sector, he noticed a gap. Popular tools like Website Carbon or EcoGrader provided a snapshot of a homepage’s emissions, but they lacked depth. They didn't account for the user's entire journey or the "dirtiness" of the energy grid at any given moment.

"I wanted something I could give to my clients so they could see their real impact," Ashley says. This spark led to the birth of EcoPigs .

The Problem with "The Homepage Grade"

Most businesses brag about an "A" rating from a carbon calculator, but Ashley warns that these grades can be dangerously misleading.

The Single-Page Trap: Most tools only measure the homepage. "If you click through to other pages, those have emissions too," Ashley notes. EcoPigs V2 evolved into a dashboard that monitors the entire site (including cookies and policies), using live visitor tracking.

The "Dirty" Evolution: A website isn't static. A developer might hand over a "Green A" site, but then the client adds a high-res video or unoptimized blog images. Suddenly, that "A" is a "C," and without constant monitoring, the owner is unknowingly claiming a sustainability status they no longer hold.

"Agreement isn't accuracy; it's just a bunch of people saying 'that will do'."

Identifying "Subconscious Greenwashing"

Perhaps the most provocative part of our conversation centred on what Ashley calls subconscious greenwashing . This happens when companies believe they are being sustainable based on flawed data models.

1. The Grid Discrepancy

Most industry-standard tools use a global average for energy grid intensity (around 494g CO2e/kWh). Ashley argues that tools can reduce the data centre portion of emissions based on a green hosting factor.

"In EcoPigs, we use live data from 28 different countries' grids that updates every 15 minutes," he says. This reveals the truth about the hosting location. For example:

Sweden: Relies heavily on hydro energy (very clean).
Poland: Relies heavily on coal (very dirty).

If both companies claim "green hosting," standard tools treat them as equals. However, if the Polish company is simply buying Renewable Energy Certificates (RECs) to "offset" their coal-powered data centre, Ashley argues the planet doesn't care. "The grid doesn't understand a certificate. The energy powering your website is still dirty.

2. The Weight of Objects

Another flaw in current logic is treating all data as equal. Current tools see a 2MB image and 2MB of JavaScript as having the same carbon footprint.

"It doesn't work that way," Ashley explains. "An image is a static download; it requires almost no compute. JavaScript requires action and processing, which uses more energy over a longer period." EcoPigs differentiates between these, measuring actual compute and energy usage rather than just file size.

Why Real-Time Monitoring Matters

The ultimate goal of EcoPigs isn't just to give a grade, but to provide a live look "under the bonnet." By using a lightweight tracking method to map real-time visitor journeys and fluctuating grid data, businesses can see their emissions rise and fall throughout the day.

As Ashley puts it, we have evolved beyond the stage of "estimated guesses." To truly combat digital greenwashing, we have to stop settling for "good enough" metrics and start looking at the hard, real-time science of how the internet actually breathes.